I want Runescape to win, because:
1. it would funny
2. i don't have Guild Wars, but i have played runescape before
and 3. i like games that are completely free, or can be played, full version, no time limit, up to a certain level or missing a few features AT LEAST, and Guild Wars doesn't meet that list, though it very nearly meets it, only being a retail game makes it miss my list
Next year, i want a good FPS or TPS to be in it, and i want that to win (War Rock, S4 League, Gunz, Soldier Front etc)
its 2009, so technically, its not Best MMORPG of 2008, its Best MMORPG of 2008/2009
runescape FTW!