How about... Games graphics vs the atmosphere of the game?
Future based shows the creativity in the game developers at its most, whereas modern they usually base their worlds off of real life.
Battlefield, hands down. The reason would be because how they always try to step up their game, and a perfect example of this is the frostbite 2...
Tough one,hmmm... probably the steriotypical huge axe XD.
wayyyy too many. And most of them are just O.K. on a side note: I really like how catacylism is with their quests now.